1. "In a differential diagnosis, include the 'mosts.' The most common, the most dangerous, and the most interesting. Though in the case of acute chest pain, skip the most interesting. Because if someone has ST elevation on their EKG and you're talking to the resident about parasitic pericarditis, they're going to hit you with the clipboard. And so they should."
2. "Speaking as an internist, every last one of you in this room has a pulmonary embolism until proven otherwise. That is something you never ever want to miss."
3. Apparently there is an outlet for my hypochondria and tendency to catastrophize: unleash it on my patients! "Put in the differential the absolute worst things it could be...the really bad shit. Because you'd feel really bad if the patient died and you had to say, 'Oh, a pneumothorax...I never thought of that!'"
4. 'If a little is good, a lot is better' does not apply to high-fiber cereal bars, no matter how tasty they may be. Remember that SNL spoof about 'Colon Blow' cereal? Back when SNL was funny? Yeah.
5. Physicians, especially ER docs, really seem to relish catching malingerers. Their eyes always light up when they talk about it, and they start grinning like feral chipmunks. For instance, someone complaining of chest pain angling for MI-type attention who says it hurts when you press *right there* is probably faking it. That's musculoskeletal. "I always tell them, oh, good, I think you're out of the woods. Peace."
6. Having whacked out hormone levels (though not, as of yet, any confirmed $%&# diagnosis) has made me a little...hairier than usual. Supposedly acne is also part of the sideshow. "At least I don't have that," I consoled myself. Wrong. Long workouts + androgens + ubiquitous bacteria = not just acne but, cruelly, ass-ne. *Is there no end to the ignominy?!?!*
7. My first hospital session (with an actual patient) is next week. I'm a little (ok, a lot) nervous. Hopefully I will not blind the patient with the ophthalmoscope or forget part of the physical or lose my train of thought during the history and just sit there staring blankly. No. All will be well.
Thursday, October 8, 2009
Sunday, October 4, 2009
Does she or doesn't she?
Only her reproductive endocrinologist knows for sure.
The 'so, do I have PCOS?' circus continues. Altered hormone levels, especially high androgens (male hormones)? Check. Irregular periods? Check. Increased (ahem) body hair? Yeah, fine, check. Obesity? Well...no, but the comorbid eating disorder could have something to do with that. So what's the most distressing? Honestly, the hair (this from someone who hasn't shaved since middle school). I feel like I'm either going through puberty again or turning into a wolf. Or possibly both. Wasn't there a book during the eighties called 'I was a teenage werewolf?' I think there was.
Americans have really...effed up responses to female body hair. When I wear shorts, I catch people staring. A lot. I wish, if they were really that curious, that they'd have the testicular fortitude (ie balls) to come up to me and say, "Hey, I think your particular style of bodily presentation is really different and kind of cool. Would you tell me a little bit about why you do things this way?" Then I might not want to disembowel them with a spoon for tee-heeing with their friends behind my back at the Metro stop. Y'know, the way I do now.
In a 1998 study, 125 undergrads of both sexes were shown 2 videos of a woman drying off after a swim. In one she was clean shaven, and in the other she had hairy armpits and legs. The unshaven woman was rated as less: moral (?!?), relaxed and fun; she was rated as more assertive, aggressive, serious and 'in better physical condition.' This was the same woman, mind you. The only difference was the presence vs. absence of hair.
A few days ago, on what I generally consider to be a feminist blog, one of the commenters (in discussing her feelings about fat acceptance vs. fatphobia) brought up the subject of choosing with whom one associates, and said, "For instance, I think women have the right not to shave if they don't want to, but I still think it's abnormal and weird and I probably wouldn't want to spend a lot of time with them." REALLY? AYFKM? (Think it out...Are You F*cking Kidding Me?) Just having looked at me, without so much as a hello, you know you don't want to chill with me based on the state of my hair follicles? Not to mention that it's NORMAL for women to have body hair--IT GROWS THERE AND WILL BE THERE UNLESS YOU ACTIVELY REMOVE IT--and so the whole "It's abnormal/weird" argument is proof positive that you've bought into the consumerist/patriarchal/western beauty complex.
The excess hair associated with PCOS is called 'hirsutism,' and it really isn't so much an excess of hair (though it can be) as it is a male-pattern hair growth--ie, on the chest, the lower stomach, the shoulders, upper lip and chin, lower back. Most people bleach it/electrolyze it/shave it. Some people, like Circus Amok performance artist Jennifer Miller (google it...you'll like it) don't. It's all part of the pulchritudinous plethora of personalities we call life. So for now, I'm going to discreetly pluck a few places...and leave the rest.
The 'so, do I have PCOS?' circus continues. Altered hormone levels, especially high androgens (male hormones)? Check. Irregular periods? Check. Increased (ahem) body hair? Yeah, fine, check. Obesity? Well...no, but the comorbid eating disorder could have something to do with that. So what's the most distressing? Honestly, the hair (this from someone who hasn't shaved since middle school). I feel like I'm either going through puberty again or turning into a wolf. Or possibly both. Wasn't there a book during the eighties called 'I was a teenage werewolf?' I think there was.
Americans have really...effed up responses to female body hair. When I wear shorts, I catch people staring. A lot. I wish, if they were really that curious, that they'd have the testicular fortitude (ie balls) to come up to me and say, "Hey, I think your particular style of bodily presentation is really different and kind of cool. Would you tell me a little bit about why you do things this way?" Then I might not want to disembowel them with a spoon for tee-heeing with their friends behind my back at the Metro stop. Y'know, the way I do now.
In a 1998 study, 125 undergrads of both sexes were shown 2 videos of a woman drying off after a swim. In one she was clean shaven, and in the other she had hairy armpits and legs. The unshaven woman was rated as less: moral (?!?), relaxed and fun; she was rated as more assertive, aggressive, serious and 'in better physical condition.' This was the same woman, mind you. The only difference was the presence vs. absence of hair.
A few days ago, on what I generally consider to be a feminist blog, one of the commenters (in discussing her feelings about fat acceptance vs. fatphobia) brought up the subject of choosing with whom one associates, and said, "For instance, I think women have the right not to shave if they don't want to, but I still think it's abnormal and weird and I probably wouldn't want to spend a lot of time with them." REALLY? AYFKM? (Think it out...Are You F*cking Kidding Me?) Just having looked at me, without so much as a hello, you know you don't want to chill with me based on the state of my hair follicles? Not to mention that it's NORMAL for women to have body hair--IT GROWS THERE AND WILL BE THERE UNLESS YOU ACTIVELY REMOVE IT--and so the whole "It's abnormal/weird" argument is proof positive that you've bought into the consumerist/patriarchal/western beauty complex.
The excess hair associated with PCOS is called 'hirsutism,' and it really isn't so much an excess of hair (though it can be) as it is a male-pattern hair growth--ie, on the chest, the lower stomach, the shoulders, upper lip and chin, lower back. Most people bleach it/electrolyze it/shave it. Some people, like Circus Amok performance artist Jennifer Miller (google it...you'll like it) don't. It's all part of the pulchritudinous plethora of personalities we call life. So for now, I'm going to discreetly pluck a few places...and leave the rest.
Monday, September 21, 2009
Fun quotes from the past week
Pulmonary lecturer: "If there's blood in the pleural space, obviously the lung can't expand there. Two bodies cannot occupy the same space at the same time...though, of course, it's fun to try."
Renal lecturer: "So if this woman has 6 liters of extra fluid on board but she doesn't have pitting edema, where did she put it?"
Student: "I don't know, in her hump?" (full disclosure, it was me.)
Professor: "What?"
Other student: "She's a camel!"
Other renal lecturer: "And if you had to guess which diuretic Peter Griffin from Family Guy is on, you would guess spironolactone. Because of the gynecomastia." (For those playing the home game, gynecomastia is when men develop hypertrophic breast tissue; in layman's terms, man-boobs).
Renal lecturer: "So if this woman has 6 liters of extra fluid on board but she doesn't have pitting edema, where did she put it?"
Student: "I don't know, in her hump?" (full disclosure, it was me.)
Professor: "What?"
Other student: "She's a camel!"
Other renal lecturer: "And if you had to guess which diuretic Peter Griffin from Family Guy is on, you would guess spironolactone. Because of the gynecomastia." (For those playing the home game, gynecomastia is when men develop hypertrophic breast tissue; in layman's terms, man-boobs).
Wednesday, September 16, 2009
Today's Lessons...
Not necessarily related to class--though some are.
1. No one ever has pheochromocytomas (tumors that produce excess adrenaline and noradrenaline), but lots of people have the symptoms. The symptoms are really common and vague--palpitations, flushing, jitteriness. As an intern, you will run lots of labs trying to track down a "pheo," imagining the 'House'-ready moment when you present your off-the-wall find to your attending and are crowned with laurels and fanned with palm leaves by the more junior medical students. One problem: you will not find them. They are the Easter Bunny, the end of the rainbow. Never there. Oh, and fun learning point: "Pheo" is a root meaning 'dusky.' Guess the tumors are dusky colored.
2. According to several people in my class, "Snickers are the healthiest candy bar. The most protein, the most fiber. No, seriously." I would say that if your eating habits have reached the point that you are SERIOUSLY considering the nutritional merits of Snickers bars, you have bigger problems than that extra 2 grams of fiber can address.
3. Not even the promise of cupcakes was sufficient to lure--I mean, encourage--more than 5 people to come to the Medical Students for Choice meeting. Why? Because another interest group was having a meeting and serving lunch. Since when does lunch beat cupcakes? Especially cupcakes with that layer of frosting that's so thick and firm you can pick it off the pastry and eat it by itself? Damn, now I'm all hungry.
4. In low-bloodflow situations, tissues (including the heart!) are capable of entering a 'hibernating' state where oxygen need is reduced and metabolism slows; upon reperfusion (ie the return of blood to the area) metabolism picks right up again, albeit with modifications--including modifications that are protective in the event of future ischemia! We are truly adaptable creatures.
5. I'm a soprano and all, but hitting a high A (as in, a ledger line above the staff) is...difficult.
6. When you're a medical student, you dissect the aorta and appreciate how thick it is, how muscular while still being elastic and distensible. When the aorta dissects itself--as in advanced syphilis or Marfan's syndrome--it's really, really bad. Rupture and exsanguinate (isn't that a great word? Better than 'bleed out,' in my opinion) in a matter of minutes bad.
7. Waiting for 45 minutes at the reproductive endocrinologist's office with only a People mazagine for company reinforced several things I already know about myself:
a) I think those over-sized sunglasses are a horrible, horrible trend, mostly because I associate them with Paris Hilton and Mary Kate Olsen. Also, they make people look like bugs.
b) I am a fundamentally impatient person. I have a need to be doing SOMEthing at all times. Maybe the Universe is teaching me to be more chill; I don't know.
c) I am out of touch with popular culture, and this does not bother me. I know who Jon and Kate are solely from check-out-stand magazines; I do not care about their family because I have other things to care about, and also because I am strangely immune to the 'cuteness rays' children emit. I spend evenings reading textbooks and writing sonnets rather than watching TV. Does this make me a better person than someone who watches Wheel of Fortune or streams cat videos on YouTube? Yes. Yes, it does.
d) There is no way to make a gyn exam not suck. There are, however, ways to make it suck less--and the rules for an easy exam are surprisingly similar to the rules for good sex. To the patient: relax. Speak up if something hurts. Breathe. For the doctor: Go slow. Explain what you'll be doing before you do it. Warm the speculum, or use a plastic one. Have lube handy. Don't be in a rush, but don't hang out in there forever.
1. No one ever has pheochromocytomas (tumors that produce excess adrenaline and noradrenaline), but lots of people have the symptoms. The symptoms are really common and vague--palpitations, flushing, jitteriness. As an intern, you will run lots of labs trying to track down a "pheo," imagining the 'House'-ready moment when you present your off-the-wall find to your attending and are crowned with laurels and fanned with palm leaves by the more junior medical students. One problem: you will not find them. They are the Easter Bunny, the end of the rainbow. Never there. Oh, and fun learning point: "Pheo" is a root meaning 'dusky.' Guess the tumors are dusky colored.
2. According to several people in my class, "Snickers are the healthiest candy bar. The most protein, the most fiber. No, seriously." I would say that if your eating habits have reached the point that you are SERIOUSLY considering the nutritional merits of Snickers bars, you have bigger problems than that extra 2 grams of fiber can address.
3. Not even the promise of cupcakes was sufficient to lure--I mean, encourage--more than 5 people to come to the Medical Students for Choice meeting. Why? Because another interest group was having a meeting and serving lunch. Since when does lunch beat cupcakes? Especially cupcakes with that layer of frosting that's so thick and firm you can pick it off the pastry and eat it by itself? Damn, now I'm all hungry.
4. In low-bloodflow situations, tissues (including the heart!) are capable of entering a 'hibernating' state where oxygen need is reduced and metabolism slows; upon reperfusion (ie the return of blood to the area) metabolism picks right up again, albeit with modifications--including modifications that are protective in the event of future ischemia! We are truly adaptable creatures.
5. I'm a soprano and all, but hitting a high A (as in, a ledger line above the staff) is...difficult.
6. When you're a medical student, you dissect the aorta and appreciate how thick it is, how muscular while still being elastic and distensible. When the aorta dissects itself--as in advanced syphilis or Marfan's syndrome--it's really, really bad. Rupture and exsanguinate (isn't that a great word? Better than 'bleed out,' in my opinion) in a matter of minutes bad.
7. Waiting for 45 minutes at the reproductive endocrinologist's office with only a People mazagine for company reinforced several things I already know about myself:
a) I think those over-sized sunglasses are a horrible, horrible trend, mostly because I associate them with Paris Hilton and Mary Kate Olsen. Also, they make people look like bugs.
b) I am a fundamentally impatient person. I have a need to be doing SOMEthing at all times. Maybe the Universe is teaching me to be more chill; I don't know.
c) I am out of touch with popular culture, and this does not bother me. I know who Jon and Kate are solely from check-out-stand magazines; I do not care about their family because I have other things to care about, and also because I am strangely immune to the 'cuteness rays' children emit. I spend evenings reading textbooks and writing sonnets rather than watching TV. Does this make me a better person than someone who watches Wheel of Fortune or streams cat videos on YouTube? Yes. Yes, it does.
d) There is no way to make a gyn exam not suck. There are, however, ways to make it suck less--and the rules for an easy exam are surprisingly similar to the rules for good sex. To the patient: relax. Speak up if something hurts. Breathe. For the doctor: Go slow. Explain what you'll be doing before you do it. Warm the speculum, or use a plastic one. Have lube handy. Don't be in a rush, but don't hang out in there forever.
Tuesday, September 8, 2009
More on Fat Acceptance...
Great article on eating disorders in the Fat Acceptance movement from my absolute favorite magazine, Bitch: Feminist Response to Pop Culture.
An article which begs the question, what exactly makes an eating disorder? Obviously it's a subjective diagnosis, whether you're talking about anorexia or binge eating disorder (yes, there are 'physical,' objective indicators of eating disorder status...a BMI below 17.5, or amenorrhea for more than 3 months for anorexia, for example) but then again, even the DSM-IV includes "overvaluation" of weight as a symptom of EDs. Think about that. In 2009, in the United States, one could reasonably argue that most women 'overvalue' their weight. Not because we're stupid or shallow or have a diagnosable eating disorder, but rather because that's what we're trained to do from elementary school on. Despite the positive spate of articles in teen-oriented magazines like Seventeen, there are still 'Summer Tone-Up Specials' published every May, showing 13 year olds that the best (and perhaps only) way to be a real woman is to watch those calories and do 100 crunches a day.
We have a slew of television shows like 'Bulging Brides' (I almost fell off the treadmill at the gym when I saw that title a few days ago) and 'The Biggest Loser' that focus exclusively on weight loss. Magazines at the check-out stand offer ways to drop 20 pounds in a month--assuming that every woman wants or needs to lose the equivalent of a small child--then, in another article a few pages later, exhort women to love themselves whatever their shape. Then, in the 'Health' column, another admonition that a body fat percentage over 20 means you're headed for an early, deep-fried grave. The whole mess is--well, a mess.
The primary point is that eating disorders occur in people of all shapes and sizes--something that most people would benefit from knowing. Officially, anorexia requires a certain percentage of weight be lost--yet I've known 'normal' and overweight people who followed profoundly restrictive diets. For a period during college, I was running ten miles a day and eating 600 calories--but it wasn't until my weight plummeted past 100 lbs that I was 'officially' anorexic. Bulimics can be any weight. Someone can binge-eat and weight 80 pounds, or 380. The fat acceptance movement is right on in encouraging people to care for their bodies--but an eating disorder, whether manifest in starving or bingeing, is profoundly unloving. For a woman attempting to heal that damage to be rejected by the very movement that purports to champion body-love is both counterproductive and disappointing. Exclusion and derision hurt, no matter what the 'political' motivations.
An article which begs the question, what exactly makes an eating disorder? Obviously it's a subjective diagnosis, whether you're talking about anorexia or binge eating disorder (yes, there are 'physical,' objective indicators of eating disorder status...a BMI below 17.5, or amenorrhea for more than 3 months for anorexia, for example) but then again, even the DSM-IV includes "overvaluation" of weight as a symptom of EDs. Think about that. In 2009, in the United States, one could reasonably argue that most women 'overvalue' their weight. Not because we're stupid or shallow or have a diagnosable eating disorder, but rather because that's what we're trained to do from elementary school on. Despite the positive spate of articles in teen-oriented magazines like Seventeen, there are still 'Summer Tone-Up Specials' published every May, showing 13 year olds that the best (and perhaps only) way to be a real woman is to watch those calories and do 100 crunches a day.
We have a slew of television shows like 'Bulging Brides' (I almost fell off the treadmill at the gym when I saw that title a few days ago) and 'The Biggest Loser' that focus exclusively on weight loss. Magazines at the check-out stand offer ways to drop 20 pounds in a month--assuming that every woman wants or needs to lose the equivalent of a small child--then, in another article a few pages later, exhort women to love themselves whatever their shape. Then, in the 'Health' column, another admonition that a body fat percentage over 20 means you're headed for an early, deep-fried grave. The whole mess is--well, a mess.
The primary point is that eating disorders occur in people of all shapes and sizes--something that most people would benefit from knowing. Officially, anorexia requires a certain percentage of weight be lost--yet I've known 'normal' and overweight people who followed profoundly restrictive diets. For a period during college, I was running ten miles a day and eating 600 calories--but it wasn't until my weight plummeted past 100 lbs that I was 'officially' anorexic. Bulimics can be any weight. Someone can binge-eat and weight 80 pounds, or 380. The fat acceptance movement is right on in encouraging people to care for their bodies--but an eating disorder, whether manifest in starving or bingeing, is profoundly unloving. For a woman attempting to heal that damage to be rejected by the very movement that purports to champion body-love is both counterproductive and disappointing. Exclusion and derision hurt, no matter what the 'political' motivations.
Saturday, September 5, 2009
Cool stuff learned in class this week
1. If you have 2 boys, roughly 13 years of age, show up together in the ER with symptoms of atropine poisoning (anticholinergic or antimuscarinic poisoning): Odds are good--ie, 90%--they heard from someone--like a 14 year old boy--that it's possible to get high by smoking a plant called Jimson Weed. The bad news is, it contains alkaloids related to those found in Atropa belladonna (otherwise known as deadly nightshade) that will make your mucous membranes dry, make you unable to pee, cause hyperthermia (ie, high temperature, but not mediated by the cellular messengers that usually cause fever), and make you kind of delirious and crazy. It's a high, sure, but it's not the nice sort of high you get from a Purple Haze or a White Widow (names, apparently, of carefully cultivated and very expensive varietals of Cannabis sativa. Ahem. Seriously, I read about it in a New Yorker article. And then learned about 'Afternoon Delight' from Arrested Development. Aside: I really don't know why marijuana isn't legal. It's exponentially safer than cigarettes, alcohol--or, for that matter, aspirin).
2. Two teen girls who show up together will probably exhibit an anticholinergic toxidrome related to motion-sickness meds (hey, if you take enough Benadryl or scopolamine you can get high!) or a sympathomimetic toxidrome (ie, be speedy, with pounding hearts and anxiety) related to drugs like amphetamines taken for weight loss.
3. There is a drug called Narcan which exists to bring people out of heroin-induced comas, but according to the lecturer, "People are usually pretty pissed off when they wake up, because you've undone the nice high they paid for."
4. There is a drug called Flumenazil that exists to undo benzodiazepine toxicity, too, but it's used much less often, and for good reason. If someone's been abusing (or even just taking regularly, as one might for insomnia or anxiety disorders) benzos, they'll be kicked into withdrawal, one sign of which is seizure. And what's the first-line treatment for seizure? Benzos, only know you can't use them, because you've blocked the receptor. Oh shit.
5. Despite having to memorize lots of drugs and mechanisms, pharmacology is pretty damn cool.
6. Pediatric neck masses are almost never cancer. In older adults, they almost always are.
7. If someone says they feel like they're 'spinning,' 90% of the time they have an inner ear problem.
2. Two teen girls who show up together will probably exhibit an anticholinergic toxidrome related to motion-sickness meds (hey, if you take enough Benadryl or scopolamine you can get high!) or a sympathomimetic toxidrome (ie, be speedy, with pounding hearts and anxiety) related to drugs like amphetamines taken for weight loss.
3. There is a drug called Narcan which exists to bring people out of heroin-induced comas, but according to the lecturer, "People are usually pretty pissed off when they wake up, because you've undone the nice high they paid for."
4. There is a drug called Flumenazil that exists to undo benzodiazepine toxicity, too, but it's used much less often, and for good reason. If someone's been abusing (or even just taking regularly, as one might for insomnia or anxiety disorders) benzos, they'll be kicked into withdrawal, one sign of which is seizure. And what's the first-line treatment for seizure? Benzos, only know you can't use them, because you've blocked the receptor. Oh shit.
5. Despite having to memorize lots of drugs and mechanisms, pharmacology is pretty damn cool.
6. Pediatric neck masses are almost never cancer. In older adults, they almost always are.
7. If someone says they feel like they're 'spinning,' 90% of the time they have an inner ear problem.
Monday, August 31, 2009
A physician-to-be looks at Fat Pride
There is a movement called Fat Pride. Marilyn Wann, the author of a book of fat activist essays entitled "Fat?So!" is widely considered to be at the forefront. It supports taking back the word 'fat,' just as the gay rights movement has taken back 'queer,' stripping it of its shameful and painful connotations. As one of my fat activist friends explained to me, "I'm fat. So what? I could say I'm Rubenesque, or generously proportioned, built for comfort and not for speed. But to the rest of the world I'm fat. Why dance around it?"
At a medical school, of course, we are taught that fat (dietary or bodily) is anathema (for those readers who majored in biochemistry and haven't read anything but Cell since sophomore year, anathema means really really bad). Virtually every lecture touches upon it in some way, from last year's biochem lecturer who seemed almost pathologically obsessed with saturated and trans fats (she cut one of her favorite baked goods out of her life entirely when she discovered they contained what I believe was 2 g of trans fat per serving--but then I speak as the person who has a hang up about fiber, which is no less pathological, and has me tallying my 25 grams a day in my daily planner)...to this year's pathology talks on cancer, in which dietary fat intake presents significant increases in malignancy risk. Obesity is a risk factor for cancer, for heart disease, for type II diabetes...yes. This is true. But there are other findings which are not discussed, and furthermore--and more disturbingly, to my mind--there is an atmosphere of...distaste for the obese that permeates our education, and which has no place in the training of future caregivers.
For one (yes, I should cite the study. Go to pubmed, and I have no doubt you'll be able to find it. I know saying 'A study said' without further citation is the gravest sin a scientist can commit. Mea maxima culpa) when overweight but cardiovascularly fit, exercising individuals and 'normal weight' but unfit individuals were tracked for seven years in a longitudinal study...the normal weight couch potatoes were at a higher risk of death. Interesting. Granted, in a social milieu that fosters sedentary life and cheerfully offers to Supersize everything, poor eating habits and inactivity often come together and produce someone who is unhealthy--and who also happens, through the normal workings of thermodynamics, to be overweight. But are all overweight people snarfing deep-fried Oreos and calling Guitar Hero their 'cardio for the day'? Of course not. Look, Grasshopper, and you will see...shades of grey. Yes, I know I spelled it the British way. I like that way better.
As for the distaste for fat people--which we medicalize and sanitize by calling 'overweight or obesity'--that is a much more malignant issue. My medical school class is not a cross-section of society by any means, perhaps most especially (and I find this intriguing) not in terms of body habitus, nor in health habits. Almost a dozen of us--out of 124--ran the St. Louis Marathon last year; many others ran the half-marathon. Today in class, I watched the snacks people were eating: four apples, one bag of carrots/celery, one bag of trail mix, a banana, and numerous diet Cokes. And as for body size, well, we are FAR below the widely cited "1 in 3" obesity statistic. Approaching, in fact, 0%. Perhaps that makes it easy for us to think of the obese as "them": it's something that happens to other people, something from which we (with our daily workouts and carefully planned 1800 calorie, low fat, high-fiber diets) are saved by our superior willpower.
I worry about this.
I worry that this will create physicians who think that nagging, insulting, preaching or condescending will get people to lose weight.
I worry that this will create physicians who think 'fat people' are to blame for all their health problems and are undeserving of sympathy and empathy.
I worry that we haven't found a way to help people who want to lose weight but can't, and that this may be partly because we think fat is a moral failing.
I worry.
At a medical school, of course, we are taught that fat (dietary or bodily) is anathema (for those readers who majored in biochemistry and haven't read anything but Cell since sophomore year, anathema means really really bad). Virtually every lecture touches upon it in some way, from last year's biochem lecturer who seemed almost pathologically obsessed with saturated and trans fats (she cut one of her favorite baked goods out of her life entirely when she discovered they contained what I believe was 2 g of trans fat per serving--but then I speak as the person who has a hang up about fiber, which is no less pathological, and has me tallying my 25 grams a day in my daily planner)...to this year's pathology talks on cancer, in which dietary fat intake presents significant increases in malignancy risk. Obesity is a risk factor for cancer, for heart disease, for type II diabetes...yes. This is true. But there are other findings which are not discussed, and furthermore--and more disturbingly, to my mind--there is an atmosphere of...distaste for the obese that permeates our education, and which has no place in the training of future caregivers.
For one (yes, I should cite the study. Go to pubmed, and I have no doubt you'll be able to find it. I know saying 'A study said' without further citation is the gravest sin a scientist can commit. Mea maxima culpa) when overweight but cardiovascularly fit, exercising individuals and 'normal weight' but unfit individuals were tracked for seven years in a longitudinal study...the normal weight couch potatoes were at a higher risk of death. Interesting. Granted, in a social milieu that fosters sedentary life and cheerfully offers to Supersize everything, poor eating habits and inactivity often come together and produce someone who is unhealthy--and who also happens, through the normal workings of thermodynamics, to be overweight. But are all overweight people snarfing deep-fried Oreos and calling Guitar Hero their 'cardio for the day'? Of course not. Look, Grasshopper, and you will see...shades of grey. Yes, I know I spelled it the British way. I like that way better.
As for the distaste for fat people--which we medicalize and sanitize by calling 'overweight or obesity'--that is a much more malignant issue. My medical school class is not a cross-section of society by any means, perhaps most especially (and I find this intriguing) not in terms of body habitus, nor in health habits. Almost a dozen of us--out of 124--ran the St. Louis Marathon last year; many others ran the half-marathon. Today in class, I watched the snacks people were eating: four apples, one bag of carrots/celery, one bag of trail mix, a banana, and numerous diet Cokes. And as for body size, well, we are FAR below the widely cited "1 in 3" obesity statistic. Approaching, in fact, 0%. Perhaps that makes it easy for us to think of the obese as "them": it's something that happens to other people, something from which we (with our daily workouts and carefully planned 1800 calorie, low fat, high-fiber diets) are saved by our superior willpower.
I worry about this.
I worry that this will create physicians who think that nagging, insulting, preaching or condescending will get people to lose weight.
I worry that this will create physicians who think 'fat people' are to blame for all their health problems and are undeserving of sympathy and empathy.
I worry that we haven't found a way to help people who want to lose weight but can't, and that this may be partly because we think fat is a moral failing.
I worry.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
